Zephyring Back to 1999: Xtina’s Second Single Changed Pop History
Zephyring 27 years ago, the one of one, vocal prodigious Xtina unleashed her classic “What a Girl Wants” as the second single from her Christina Aguilera self-titled debut album. Not bad for a teenager whose first hit, “Genie in a Bottle,” had already conquered the summer of 1999.
But the hit jammer that took over radio was not even the recording listeners first heard on the album. A newly produced version was prepared for the single campaign, with RCA advertising a November 8, 1999 radio-add date. The brighter, more immediate arrangement put that spectacular voice front and center, even as Aguilera was still navigating an industry eager to place its young female stars neatly into a pop category.
Discover More
Christina Aguilera: The Debut-Era Sound
Explore the official source and related picks curated around this story.
Some links may be affiliate links. INYIM may earn from qualifying purchases.
The song, written by Shelly Peiken and Guy Roche, also proved her debut was never destined to be a one-hit moment. Where “Genie in a Bottle” established Aguilera as a new pop contender, “What a Girl Wants” made her vocal agility impossible to ignore. Those early comparisons with Mariah Carey were not merely about big notes; it was the control, runs and confidence in the delivery that set Xtina apart from her peers.
And then came the chart history. On the Billboard Hot 100 dated January 15, 2000, “What a Girl Wants” climbed to No. 1, replacing Santana and Rob Thomas’s “Smooth.” It became Aguilera’s second consecutive chart-topper and spent two weeks in the top spot. More deliciously, it was the first new No. 1 of the 2000s—Billboard noted that this made Aguilera the first female artist to launch a new decade with a fresh chart-topper in the rock era.
For a song that arrived in the final stretch of 1999, “What a Girl Wants” seemed perfectly made for the changing of the guard. The millennium was turning, teen pop was everywhere, and Christina was making it very clear that being a pop star and being a serious vocalist were not mutually exclusive.
Christina Aguilera’s “What a Girl Wants” 1999-Era Imagery and Single Artwork
From the early promotional imagery to the single’s familiar artwork, the visuals belong to an era when every release felt like an event. The self-titled debut’s success helped set the stage for a remarkable evolution—one in which Aguilera would eventually push far beyond the musical expectations of her teenage introduction.
The song found fresh life in 2024 when Aguilera welcomed Sabrina Carpenter for a duet version of “What a Girl Wants” as part of the 25th-anniversary celebration of her debut album. Hearing the two voices together made a rather lovely point: a great pop record can belong to its original moment and still have something to say to the next generation.
And for anyone who remembers exactly where they were when the original single ruled radio, those opening notes still bring back the turn of the millennium with astonishing speed. The look, the sound, thee voice—what a girl wanted then was a whole lot of Christina, and she delivered.
Christina Aguilera “What a Girl Wants” Anniversary Reel
Open the anniversary reel on Instagram.
Sources: Billboard, January 15, 2000; RCA Records radio trade advertisement, November 1999; Sony Music, 2024 anniversary release.
